Since my sit down with Jeff Kelly, I have really been stuck on this one idea that, despite all the various kinds of people and different cultural backgrounds that make up Boston, movies have really focused mainly on the Irish in Charlestown. It's baffling. There's so much history and culture that has yet to be captured on film and to me, that's a problem. As a result, I challenged myself to look for ways to make movies based off of the different regions of Boston: The North End, Chinatown, Jamaica Plains, etc.My best attempts to find a good plot worth making a movie out of ended up being a lot tougher than I imagined. It was right as I was about to give up (call it a cliche I don't care) that I found a book under my bed that answered everything. I had to read it last semester for one of my English classes and, even though it does get into the history of Charlestown, it focuses on a very big piece of Boston history surrounding the Civil Rights movement: J. Anthony Lukas'
Common Ground.
Common Ground was published in 1985 and looks at race, civil rights, and segregation in Boston through the introduction of desegregated busing in Boston the 60's and the 70's. The entire book follows the lives of three different families with three different views on busing: the Irish McGoff family in Charlestown, the African-American Twymons, and the Yankee Divers.
Yes, the story still does involve the Irish and Charlestown, but there is a critical focus on how Charlestown had come to be. Most stories about Charlestown focus on current life in "The Town". A
Common Ground movie would be more focused on the why. Also, it brings in other cultures and their history in Boston with the middle to upper class Irish (the Divers) and the lower class African Americans (Twymons). With so much of a focus on segregation and the Civil Rights movement, this movie is guaranteed to not be leaning heavily in favor of Charlestown.
As I mentioned before when I discussed the making of a Boston Strong movie, there should not be any kind of big name cast in a movie like this. To bring recognizable and well-known actors into a project like this makes for a huge risk because then the viewer has the ability to leach onto one actor and then focus on one of the three families over the other. Much like the brothers who could not over shadow the firefighters and police officers for
Boston Strong: The Movie, no one family can over shadow the others for the sake of depicting three equal perspectives on busing in Boston.
There's one final thing that I think gives
Common Ground the potential to be a great movie: the fact that it is both true and, historically speaking, recent. Many of the people that Lukas wrote about are still alive. To me, that is a big opportunity to provide credibility and a sense of reality to the movie. However, it has the risk of losing the viewer if they watch first-hand interviews or anything of that sort. I think the actual movie should have some real flash back clips of Boston during this time, but I think it would be neat to incorporate the people that are still alive much in the same way that
Schindler's List had done. The actor/actress was paired up with the actual Holocaust survivor that they were portraying in the movie. I think some sort of recognition and visual of the actual person and what they are currently doing (much in the same way that Lukas concludes the book with) would be a great way to end the movie.
So, there's my idea. I can now officially say that if anyone tries to go for it, I can take some credit. It's a shame that Lukas has passed away and will therefore make this a much more difficult book to convert into a movie. It would definitely be worth it though. Why? Because I am absolutely positive that it can make a big impact on people looking for both Civil Rights history as well as the background on more than just the Irish part of Boston.